Explicit For-Profit funding model

May 29, 2007

Picture_3
I’m at TechSquared in the Economic Sustainability forum.

Here, as everywhere, there is a concept that if something provides a value, even to a mission-driven organization, the organization should charge money.

However people don’t always have money…particularly people who mission-driven organizations feel are their core beneficiaries.

So the question is, if something definitely provides value that investors would like to see monetized, can other assets be built up as intermediate component that can then provide at least compensatory non-monetary value to the organization or even be monetized by entities that are for-profit?

I just sketched a framework (attached), but off the top of my head other forms of payment in lieu of financial would include volunteering — of direct benefit to the mission-driven organization — but also components that for-profits might be able to consider monetizeable services, such as adding knowledge (even knowledge in terms of documenting experience of those who are program recipients), building reciprocal relationships, participating in research study, or finding information or even contributing “micro-information.”

Read the rest of this entry »


New Leaders’ Litmus Test

May 4, 2007

In Ted Rall’s column this week (CHOOSE ONE: LOYALTY OR GLORY) he points out how people in key positions needing to speak up when it makes a difference.

I’ve said it elsewhere, but after a recent Ten Year Forecast with Institute for the Future, where work was done on citizens’ Superhero attributes I was struck by how much it felt to  me that the 25-45 crowd was explaining how the world has changed to the 45-65 (plus?) crowd.  In other words, it’s another one of those Generation X Leadership moments.

If Viet Nam was a litmus test where Boomers thought deeply about the nature of violence within society and what an individuals’ role and responsibiity was to themself, their nation, and their world, then adjusting the political world — in all organizations: philanthropic, corporate, and NGO — is the purview of Gen X.

Whom are you willing to be loyal to? For how long? Why would you stop? Under what circumstances would you choose to put those you protect at short-term risk because of your convictions about long-term risks?

Read the rest of this entry »


Sensible Investing Quiz: How HIP Is Your Company?

May 3, 2007

FastCompany’s April issue has a section on Sustainable Investing, created by SVT Group and HIP Investor, founded by Paul Herman.

The section is very accessible to people who are unfamiliar or newly acquainted with the topic and does a good job of creating a comprehensive framework for those who like comprehensive frameworks.

One of the things I like about this approach is that it creates an accessible way for any company to begin thinking about how they deal with key areas of investment.  For example, the How HIP Is Your Company? quiz helps people conceive of the areas in which they might focus.

I also enjoyed the graph Driving Profit Through Impact that plotted Revenue against HIP practices, complete with a summary and clickthrough to a scorecard.

Read the rest of this entry »


Sustainability Reporting in XBRL

April 19, 2007

Socialfunds.com, a fabulous site, has relayed that the Global Reporting Initiaitive has released a draft taxonomy based on their G3 recommendations for the XBRL reporting framework.

Read the rest of this entry »


Baby boomers and Generation X

April 15, 2007

I’ve been thinking about other boundaries recently, but when retrieving my morning coffee, listening to my iTunes, I realized that I’ve found the (unintentionally) perfect song about Boomer / GenX interactions — an interesting topic for me as I think about Generation X leadership strengths. It’s “While My Guitar Gently Weeps.” I think it ironically captures the frustrations I’ve seen from both sides, yet told by the (Boomer) singer who simultaneously condemns the people he’s observing while recognizing that he sees potential there but can’t help them attain it because somehow playing the guitar is more important. He sits and sings about how heartbreaking it is that things have gotten to this point.

Read the rest of this entry »


Assassination Markets

April 14, 2007

I’ve been doing some work in Prediction Markets for IFTF, and have been particularly interested in the concept of assassination markets:  I predict this person will die can be transformed into a price on their head.

The thing that’s fascinating is that markets have positivity and negativity built into them all the time.  However, with prediction markets, it becomes explicit.  A new betting site, BetUs.com, allows people to bet on specific outcomes for global warming.

Will new types of regulation spring up to eliminate the possibility of creating markets in destruction? 

Read the rest of this entry »


Porter and Kramer CSR Framework

April 11, 2007

I’m a big fan of Michael Porter‘s, so I was pleasantly surprised to see that an article (.pdf) about the framework devised by him and Mark Kramer to re-examine Corporate Social Responsibility was granted the 2006 McKinsey Award by Harvard Business Review.

The fundamentally new part of this article is the explicit comment that the need is to change the adversarial relationship between business and society into a collaborative one; the authors review current approaches and offer commentary about their framework.

I actually feel this framework doesn’t go quite far enough — though I haven’t talked to either of the authors so this may be simply because of the article scope — but it *seems* that they’re saying that there needs to be collaboration
across the boundary or in the interface between firm and non-firm.  In contrast, I’m
saying that the concept of externalities is outmoded now that we can model complex systems, and a new model needs to be developed that treats firms, community groups, etc. — down to the individual level — as actors in a larger topology.

Read the rest of this entry »


Working for free

April 3, 2007

In What the MySpace generation should know about working for free – ‘journalisms’ – Collectivate.net, Trebor Scholz comments “I, for one, don’t sign off on the fucked up naturalization of the exploitation labor that is so dear to capitalism.”

I want to make clear that this isn’t “dear to capitalism,” but rather a dysfunction inherent to the way capitalism is currently structured; it’s brokenness requires regulatory intervention.

This has been used before, for example to prohibit things like hiring six-year-olds because they fit into tight spaces much better than those huge 11-year-olds do. Aggregating public comment for private gain is a sure-fire way to make money. It’s also a breakdown of capitalism in the same sense that a set of monopolies is not a capitalist economy. This breakdown is what happens when people are willing to give up just a little bit and someone else is enriched. But this isn’t tossing a dollar into a street musician’s case. As Trebor points out,

“By posting User Content to any part of the Site, you automatically grant, and you represent and warrant that you have the right to grant, to the Company an irrevocable, perpetual, non-exclusive, transferable, fully paid, worldwide license (with the right to sublicense) to use, copy, publicly perform, publicly display, reformat, translate, excerpt (in whole or in part) and distribute such User Content…“

In other words, you have handed over control of your content in perpetuity.

Read the rest of this entry »


A new innovest index – Access to Medicine

April 1, 2007

A new type of sustainability index is at access-to-medicine.org.  Well named by Innovest, it’s an index that attempts to measure access to medicine.  The key indicators for performance are listed below.  (…from their site, where they also list a non-profit heavy — not pharmaceutical-heavy — list of stakeholders):

The key indicators for performance are:

20% Access to Medicines Management
20% Research & Development into Neglected Diseases
18% Equitable Pricing
15% Patents & Licensing
10% Policy Influence & Lobbying
7% Drug Donations
5% Philanthropic Activities
5% Ethical Promotion & Marketing Activities

Read the rest of this entry »


California School Report

March 19, 2007

A report alleging the California public school FINANCIAL SYSTEM is broken is picked up far and wide, notably in the New York Times.

Some key points in the Summary Report I want to comment upon:

Voluntary contributions of money, and more importantly, time also add to variation in resources across districts.  While monetary contributions to schools get substantial attention and are large in a small number of schools, on average they account for less than two percent of funds to schools for operating expenditures (Loeb, Grissom and Strunk, 2007/GDTF).  Brunner and Imazeki (2004) find that monetary contributions averaged less than $40 per pupil in 2001. On the other hand, voluntary contributions of time appear to be substantial… Principals in higher income communities reported substantially more frequent use of volunteers to provide clerical work, adult supervision at morning arrival or playground duty, tutoring, and help running sports activities than did principals in poorer communities.  …  Overall the difference in
volunteer time between low-income and high-income schools appears to be a greater source of resource disparity than are contributed dollars. (Emphasis theirs.)

Read the rest of this entry »


Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free